I am a big fan of Jean-Claude Ellena. If I organize my fragrances by nose his fragrances represent by far a plurality, maybe even a majority. I've been less fond of his recent perfumes, though, perhaps because he has reached a stage in his career where his work consists on tight variations on a single theme, namely a particular (and very good) vegetal/mineralic theme in a stripped-down key. For better or worse, two of his recent works for Hermes are again a return to this theme.
Un Jardin Sur Le Toit is the newest in the Jardin series. It is a good fragrance, no question, but if you have any of the others this will not be new to you: swap out the mango in Jardin Sur Le Nil for bright, tart apple and et voila. If you're unfamiliar with the series then this is as good a place to start as any but I can't say this evokes strong emotions. The danger of Ellena's brand of stripped-down directness is that it can sacrifice beauty for simplicity. There's nothing inherently wrong with that, but at a certain point one wants more to eat than just a well-plated appetizer.
Jour d'Hermes fares better. It's a feminine fragrance in the modern style which Ellena himself had a big part in creating: limpid and serene, the floral equivalent of a freshly scrubbed face with no adornment. The notes are seamlessly blended; individual flowers can't be discerned. On the floral fragrance axis with soliflores on one end, Jour d'Hermes defines the opposite end. Ellena's vegetal base again makes a welcome appearance here. How much one likes this will be a matter of taste: if you prefer Ellena's style to the bolder florals of classic French perfumery then you most certainly will want this. As for me, I like my florals to be grander, along the lines of Amouage's massive Honour Woman; but I certainly wouldn't turn it down if someone gave me a bottle of Jour d'Hermes.
Showing posts with label hermes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label hermes. Show all posts
Wednesday, May 29, 2013
Thursday, April 22, 2010
Voyage d'Hermès and Jean-Claude Ellena

Jean-Claude Ellena is, without question, one of the best and most innovative noses working today, and his work for Hermès represents some of the best work he's done. One of the striking aspects of his fragrances is that he is unafraid to return to various themes and permute them in various directions. The peppery top-notes of Cartier Declaration occur, in purified form, as the central element of Poivre Samarcande; the cumin in Declaration makes a strong appearance in Cologne Bigarade, one of three fragrances Ellena created for Frederic Malle; the light vegetal elements found in Kelly Caleche also recur in the Jardin trio; the sparkling grapefruit in Eau de Pamplemousse Rose pops up again in Rose Ikebana, and the rose in those two fragrances grounds Cologne Bigarade; the savory bergamote of Divine Bergamote provides a citric top-note for Eau d'Hiver.
Because of this, Ellena is sometimes (unfairly) accused of plagiarizing himself. These recurrent themes don't represent laziness, but rather a return to the same ideas, a technique followed by many artists with a mature style. Having said this, there are times when certain themes give diminishing returns, and unfortunately this is the case with Voyage d'Hermès. Here, Ellena marries the gin-soaked vegetation of Angeliques Sous la Pluie (another of his fragrances for Frederic Malle) with the sweet ginger base of Declaration.
EDIT: Upon reflection some years later, Angeliques Sous la Pluie is awesome. I was insane when I wrote this.
Saturday, March 27, 2010
The Hermessences: An Appreciation
Poivre Samarcande: A striking mixture of musk, dry woods, and black pepper, this fragrance is completely sui generis in its spare elegance. Ellena has circled similar ideas in the past, and Poivre Samarcande resembles an angular, rigorous version of his Cartier Declaration, stripped to its bare essence and then magnified. Contrary to various odd claims, it lasts for a long time on the skin: one spray can be detected a full 8 hours later. Simply the best pepper fragrance out there.
Rose Ikebana: In some ways, this is the most difficult of the line to come to terms with, paradoxically because it is the most accessible on first sniff: it is deceptively easy to dismiss Rose Ikebana as just another (exceptionally) pretty face in the crowd. Upon repeated visits, however, it becomes clear that Ellena has once again shown his mastery of simplicity. Rose Ikebana reads, as with many of Ellena's fragrances, as a reworking of past themes: in this case, the crisp citrus of Divine Bergamote and Eau de Pamplemousse Rose is balanced by an ethereal rose note. Simple, beautiful, and a must-smell for those think they don't like rose fragrances.
Paprika Brasil: This is the most underrated of the line. It is also one of the most distinctive; like Poivre Samarcande, there's nothing else out there that smells quite like this. Ellena frequently works with spices, and this is his take on the capsaicin (spicy pepper) note. It works beautifully: a hot pepper accord mingles with basil and iris to create the olfactory version of spicy-sweet food. Odd at first, it quickly establishes itself as a remarkable comfort scent.
Vanille Galant: The only disappointment among the Hermèssences, Vanille Galant mixes a wonderful, non-gourmand vanilla accord with an unfortunate melon note. Melon is a difficult note in general, and its inclusion here proves to be unpleasant.
Osmanthe Yunnan: Despite Luca Turin's rave review in Perfumes: The Guide, this is not the best of the Hermessences, although it is quite good. This is the drier, tea-infused sibling to Paprika Brasil and Rose Ikebana: very well done, but like many polite tea scents it struggles to make itself heard.
Vetiver Tonka: The best "friendly" vetiver in existence, full stop. Other vetivers can lay claim to being a truer representation of the material (Vetiver Extraordinaire, for example), but Vetiver Tonka moves in the opposite direction: its mixture of warm rootiness and savory caramel results in a perfect balance between dark and sweet. The absurdly long drydown is shockingly beautiful. Thematically, VT is a departure: deep and full, it does not have the same haiku-like simplicity of the rest of the Hermèssences.
Ambre Narguile: Some have compared this to the Serge Lutens orientals, but they are wrong: Unlike the Lutens fragrances, Ambre Narguile doesn't make me immediately nauseous. By far the thickest and warmest of the Hermessences, AN is, like Vetiver Tonka, a departure from the rest of the line in its opulence and complexity. Rich ambers mix with dried fruit and tobacco to create the perfume equivalent of a roaring fire. It might skirt the edge of being too much, but unlike most ambers out there it is never boring.
Overall, the Hermèssences are impressively unique: most of them smell unlike anything else out there, and the ones that do fall into a recognizable category (fruity floral for Rose Ikebana, woody vetiver for Vetiver Tonka) stand among the best in their class. Anyone claiming to write this line off as pretentious simplicity is welcome to drown in a vat of Ambre Sultan: there is nothing pretentious about these fragrances. Indeed, they just smell really fucking good, and isn't that what perfume is supposed to do?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)